Will your blog be banned in Australia?

August 6, 2008 – 7:28 pm

Pornographic websites won’t be the only sites blacklisted in Australia if mandatory ISP filtering is introduced. Your blog might be as well.

Many innocent blogs are likely to be banned

The recent trial of ISP filters in Tasmania showed that at best 1 out of every 100 websites were incorrectly identified and blocked. That’s bad news for bloggers. The very nature of how and why we publish blogs means we’re a prime target for being banned when we shouldn’t be.

For starters, blogs are often written in a casual tone and the odd swear word isn’t uncommon, nor is the use of slang words. No doubt one or two of us have written ‘boobs’ instead of ‘breasts.’ It’s how we speak. Unlike a company’s website where content often remains dry and stale, blogs are full of broad and erratic vocabulary.

Secondly, most of us don’t just blog about one topic, we blog about everything and we do it daily. The more diverse our content, the bigger the risk an ISP filter will incorrectly identify one of our posts and ban us.

Think of how many bloggers posted about the Bill Henson debacle that never usually touched such issues. Pet blogs, gardening blogs, everyone was having their say.

To a mandatory filter that sort of discussion is going to set off alarm bells and there’s a good chance your blog could be blocked. If you ever made post about abortion, drug abuse, or sex, your chances of beating a filter aren’t any better.

And if the list of banned sites remains anything like the current ACMA blacklist which is supplied to software filtering companies, getting your site unbanned (or ‘whitelisted’) may well be impossible. No one knows whose listed on the existing one, let alone has the ability to appeal a decision.

If Telstra or Sony’s website was incorrectly blocked it’d likely be noticed and given the all-clear, but whose going to watch out for your blog about cooking that made the mistake of mentioning chicken breasts one time too many.

For anyone who plugs away day in day out on their blog, or relies on it for work, we all know that no collateral damage is acceptable, let alone 1 - 8%. Sure, you might never be blocked, but is it worth the risk?

No Clean FeedConsider adding the No Clean Feed button to your site if you’d like to help put an end to the Government’s mandatory filtering plan.

Subscribe to RSS FEEDStay up to date with censorship issues affecting Australia by subscribing to my RSS feed. Click here.

You can also be notified of updates by email. Simply enter your email address:

Delivered by FeedBurner

  1. 12 Responses to “Will your blog be banned in Australia?”

  2. Do you know if Get-Up are on to this? I wonder what this means if I have websites hosted i germany, that they decide to filter out.

    By Sean the Blogonaut on Aug 6, 2008

  3. Hi Sean,

    As far as I know Getup aren’t acting on it yet. At least at a public level.

    If they decide to filter a site you have hosted in Germany, it will be blocked only to Australians. If it’s hosted in Australia, they can issue a take down notice, depending on the content.

    By Mike on Aug 7, 2008

  4. Mate, Love your work, Just discovered your site via Kwoff. Keep Going!

    By don on Aug 8, 2008

  5. Cheers Don!

    By Mike on Aug 8, 2008

  6. A friend who works for a Govt agency in turf management had trouble getting emails from one of his contractors - the trouble - the mention of “wet spots” seem to throw the agency filter into a frenzy… we’re talking wet spots on footy ovals mind you! If this is the clunky kind of dumbness we’ll have to deal with, I give up.

    By ell on Aug 10, 2008

  7. Another fine example, Ell. Cheers.

    By Mike on Aug 11, 2008

  8. Why would GetUp! do anything about this? They are a labor front group and this is being pushed by a labor government. GetUp! only had 1 concrete policy: “We hate John Howard”. They weren’t civil rights activists.

    By Yobbo on Oct 28, 2008

  9. @Yobbo. Do you have a source for this or is it only your unsupported opinion. While I won’t rely on GetUp! to fight my battles for me, they have done a lot of good in raising awareness of many issues.

    By Stevian on Oct 28, 2008

  10. Steve dude, they were at the federal election handing out how to vote cards with Labor as (1).

    By Yobbo on Oct 30, 2008

  11. We’ll call that the lesser of two evils, shall we.
    This from the GetUp! website:
    “GetUp does not back any particular party, but aims to build an accountable and progressive Parliament - a Parliament with economic fairness, social justice and environment at its core.”
    and I’ve asked them what there stance on censorship is, I’ll let you know what they say.

    By Stevian on Oct 30, 2008

  1. 2 Trackback(s)

  2. Aug 13, 2008: Will your blog be banned? « Public Polity
  3. Oct 18, 2008: Mandatory filtering gets international coverage - Somebody Think Of The Children

Post a Comment